HELENA – The case against the two men accused of killing Donna Meagher in 1994 has been dismissed, following their release from prison in April and their murder convictions overturned.
Montana’s Attorney General’s Office motioned to dismiss the case against Freddie Lawrence and Paul Jenkins June First, 2018 citing “The State is continuing to investigate the newly discovered evidence presented at the March 9, 2018 hearing.”
Lewis and Clark County District Court Judge Kathy Seeley ordered the dismissal without prejudice for both Lawrence and Jenkins. Also, the previously scheduled status hearing has been vacated.
Montana Department of Justice Communications Director Eric Sell said in a statement issued to MTN, “As the case has been dismissed without prejudice, charges against these men could be brought again if the state believes evidence warrants such action. The state is still investigating [David] Nelson’s connection to the crime scene.”
At a hearing in March, new evidence was presented showing that there was no DNA at the scene matching either Jenkins or Lawrence. However, DNA did match that of David Nelson. Nelson is a known criminal with a history of violent kidnappings and robberies and is currently serving time for a double homicide in Deer Lodge.
Judge Seeley’s ruling also states both Lawrence and Jenkins are free from previously ordered conditions of release.
Meagher family speaks following release of Jenkins and Lawerence
Montana Innocence Project marks “day of gratitude and celebration”
DNA just one tool to review old cases in Montana
After having murder conviction overturned, Montana man adjusts to life outside prison walls
Judge orders Paul Jenkins and Freddie Lawrence released from prison
Daughter reacts to news of father jailed for 1994 murder, who may be freed
Montana Innocence Project reacts to decision in 1994 murder convictions
Court hearing begins to determine if 2 Montana men were wrongly convicted in 1994 murder
Upcoming court hearing for 1994 murder case
DNA evidence points to possible new killer in decades-old murder case
MT Innocence Project asks for more DNA testing in 1994 murder case